In Seattle I speak to landlords and property managers every day. Nobody on my calls asks whether rooms will rent. They ask what happens when someone stops paying.
That question comes up so often that I started to notice a pattern. It is not a side concern. It is the concern. People can talk about a proforma for a few minutes. Then they want to know what happens if the rent does not arrive.
Three conversations in one month gave me three versions of the same fear.
Three conversations, the same worry
The first was an operator who walked me through the math no one puts in a pro forma. In her experience, you can lose a lot of time before you can even start the formal process of getting a unit back. "That's half a month's rent gone before anything starts."
She had also had a tenant do $20,000 in damage. Insurance paid nothing.
That is two different fears sitting in the same conversation: the wait, and the loss that is not covered when you thought it would be. I could hear how much those experiences still shaped the way she looked at risk.
The second was an investor who told me about a tenant who hadn't paid rent in over a year. "She's just working the system." He was still dealing with it. That one experience was reshaping his entire strategy.
A year is a long time to carry a unit that is not doing what you underwrote it to do. It is also a long time to live with the feeling that you cannot get your asset back. I heard a person who was changing his whole approach because of one unpaid tenancy.
The third described a tenant who stopped paying, and luckily just left. His word was, "fortunately we didn't have to bring in attorneys."
Think about that. The good outcome, in that version of traditional rentals, is that the person who owes you money disappears, because the alternative is a lawyer. "Fortunately" is a revealing word. It means the bar for a decent ending has gotten very low.
This is the real objection right now
This is the real objection to rental real estate that I hear right now. Not cap rates. Not interest rates. The fear that one person can hold your asset hostage, and that you will have to wait in line to get it back.
I understand why that fear takes up so much room. I have my own early story of unpaid rent, legal fees, and a long, draining process, which I wrote about in Mistakes I Made as a Seattle Landlord, and What Changed. Once you have lived that, it is hard to look at a new property without seeing it in the background.
The figures I have seen put the average eviction in the $3,500 to $10,000 range, once you count legal fees, lost rent, and turnover. Landlords recover about 17% of unpaid rent through collections. Most investors don't underwrite for this. They just hope.
Hope isn't a risk strategy.
I think a lot of owners know this risk is there and still don't build it into the way they buy or operate. It is easier to assume it will not happen to you, until it does.
Price the risk, then structure around it
The operators who last are the ones who price this risk and structure around it.
That can sound abstract, so I will keep it as plain as the conversations themselves. If the thing that would actually hurt you is non-payment, damage, and time, then those have to be part of how you look at a deal. Not as a footnote. As a real cost that some owners have already paid.
I don't pretend the fear is irrational. I do think there is a difference between hoping it will not happen and being honest about what you will do if it does.
This is also why I try to keep these conversations practical. If you want a starting point for common questions from landlords and property managers, I keep a Frequently Asked Questions page, and more of My Story is on the site if you want the background on why this subject sits close to me. You can also Get in Touch if you'd rather write than book a call.
I still want to hear from other owners. What's your worst non-payment story, and what do you actually do to prevent it? The three conversations I shared here are not rare. They are the ones I keep hearing from people who are trying to keep doing this work in Seattle.
The rooms, in my experience, are not the hard part. The hard part is knowing what you will do when the rent stops, and building a plan that does not depend on hope.
FAQ
What do Seattle landlords ask you about most?
On my calls, nobody asks whether rooms will rent. They ask what happens when someone stops paying. I heard three versions of that same fear in one month, including unpaid rent that lasted over a year, a $20,000 damage claim insurance did not cover, and a "good" outcome that simply meant the person left so attorneys did not have to get involved.
What can an eviction actually cost?
The figures I have seen put the average eviction at $3,500 to $10,000 once you count legal fees, lost rent, and turnover. Landlords recover about 17% of unpaid rent through collections. Most investors I talk with don't underwrite for this. They just hope, and hope is not a risk strategy.
Let's talk
If you want to talk through risk, a property, or what you're seeing with non-payment, Book a Call. You can also email me at suzanne.vetillart@padsplit.com.